Current:Home > InvestKansas Constitution does not include a right to vote, state Supreme Court majority says -Dynamic Wealth Solutions
Kansas Constitution does not include a right to vote, state Supreme Court majority says
View
Date:2025-04-18 10:33:18
The Kansas Supreme Court offered a mixed bag in a ruling Friday that combined several challenges to a 2021 election law, siding with state officials on one provision, reviving challenges to others and offering the possibility that at least one will be halted before this year’s general election.
But it was the ballot signature verification measure’s majority opinion — which stated there is no right to vote enshrined in the Kansas Constitution’s Bill of Rights — that drew fiery dissent from three of the court’s seven justices.
The measure requires election officials to match the signatures on advance mail ballots to a person’s voter registration record. The state Supreme Court reversed a lower court’s dismissal of that lawsuit, but the majority rejected arguments from voting rights groups that the measure violates state constitutional voting rights.
In fact, Justice Caleb Stegall, writing for the majority, said that the dissenting justices wrongly accused the majority of ignoring past precedent, holding that the court has not identified a “fundamental right to vote” within the state constitution.
“It simply is not there,” Stegall wrote.
Justice Eric Rosen, one of the three who dissented, shot back: “It staggers my imagination to conclude Kansas citizens have no fundamental right to vote under their state constitution.”
“I cannot and will not condone this betrayal of our constitutional duty to safeguard the foundational rights of Kansans,” Rosen added.
Conversely, the high court unanimously sided with the challengers of a different provision that makes it a crime for someone to give the appearance of being an election official. Voting rights groups, including Kansas League of Women Voters and the nonprofit Loud Light, argued the measure suppresses free speech and their ability to register voters as some might wrongly assume volunteers are election workers, putting them at risk of criminal prosecution.
A Shawnee County District Court judge had earlier rejected the groups’ request for an emergency injunction, saying that impersonation of a public official is not protected speech.
But the high court faulted the new law, noting that it doesn’t include any requirement that prosecutors show intent by a voter registration volunteer to misrepresent or deceive people into believing they’re an election official, and it thus “criminalizes honest speech” where “occasional misunderstandings” are bound to occur, Stegall wrote in the majority opinion.
“As such, it sweeps up protected speech in its net,” Stegall said.
Because the lawsuit over the false impersonation law’s constitutionality is likely to succeed, the state Supreme Court ordered the lower court to reconsider issuing an emergency injunction against it.
“For three years now, Kansas League of Women Voters volunteers have been forced to severely limit their assistance of voters due to this ambiguous and threatening law,” said Martha Pint, president of the chapter. “The League’s critical voter assistance work is not a crime, and we are confident this provision will be quickly blocked when the case returns to the district court.”
Loud Light executive director Davis Hammet said he hopes the lower court “will stop the irreparable harm caused daily by the law and allow us to resume voter registration before the general election.”
Neither Kansas Secretary of State Scott Schwab nor state Attorney General Kris Kobach responded to requests for comment on that portion of the high court’s ruling.
Instead, in a joint statement, Schwab and Kobach focus on the high court’s language bolstering the signature verification law and its upholding of a provision that says individuals may collect no more than 10 advance ballots to submit to election officials.
“This ruling allows us to preserve reasonable election security laws in Kansas,” Schwab said.
Supporters have argued the ballot collection restriction combats “ballot harvesting” and limits voter fraud. The GOP-led Legislature passed it over a veto by Kansas Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly. Critics have said it’s a Republican reaction to baseless claims that the 2020 election was not valid, which prompted a wave of misinformation and voter suppression laws across the country.
Last year, the Kansas Court of Appeals reinstated a lawsuit challenging the ballot collection limitation and the signature verification, saying both impair the right to vote. But the high court upheld the limit on ballot collections, saying “voters have numerous avenues available to deliver their ballots” and that ballot collecting doesn’t fall within the parameters of free speech.
Kobach defended the majority’s opinion as “well-reasoned” and confirms that the Legislature has the constitutional authority to establish proofs “to ensure voters are who they say they are.”
“And that is exactly what Kansas’s signature verification requirement is,” Kobach said.
veryGood! (32)
Related
- Have Dry, Sensitive Skin? You Need To Add These Gentle Skincare Products to Your Routine
- This week on Sunday Morning: By Design (August 20)
- A large ice chunk fell from the sky and damaged a house in Massachusetts
- Woman dragged by truck after Facebook Marketplace trade went wrong
- Bill Belichick's salary at North Carolina: School releases football coach's contract details
- Investment scams are everywhere on social media. Here’s how to spot one
- Videos show flames from engine of plane that returned to Houston airport after takeoff
- 4 Australian tourists rescued after going missing at sea off Indonesia for 2 days
- Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
- The Blind Side Author Weighs in on Michael Oher Claims About the Tuohy Family
Ranking
- Why we love Bear Pond Books, a ski town bookstore with a French bulldog 'Staff Pup'
- 'Hot Ones' spicy chicken strips now at stores nationwide; Hot Pockets collab coming soon
- How to prepare for hurricane season, according to weather experts
- Spam, a staple in Hawaii, is sending 265,000 cans of food to Maui after the wildfires: We see you and love you.
- Dick Vitale announces he is cancer free: 'Santa Claus came early'
- Former district attorney in western Pennsylvania gets prison time for attacking a woman
- Aldi to buy 400 Winn-Dixie and Harveys Supermarket grocery stores across the Southeast
- Calling all shoppers: Vote for the best grocery stores and butcher shops in the US
Recommendation
NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
Hawaii governor vows to block land grabs as fire-ravaged Maui rebuilds
Microsoft exec Jared Bridegan's ex, Shanna Gardner, is now charged in plot to murder him
NCAA conference realignment shook up Big 10, Big 12 and PAC-12. We mapped the impact
Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
Biden will use Camp David backdrop hoping to broker a breakthrough in Japan-South Korea relations
Brazilian hacker claims Bolsonaro asked him to hack into the voting system ahead of 2022 vote
Britney Spears and husband Sam Asghari separate after 14 months of marriage: Reports